Search GKGrades.com

Showing posts with label Kansas City Wizards. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kansas City Wizards. Show all posts

Saturday, May 15, 2010

Jimmy Nielsen - Kansas City Wizards - MLS - 05.05.2010

Final: Kansas City Wizards 1, DC United 2
RFK Stadium, Washington D.C.
MLS - Major League Soccer
05/05/2010

Jimmy Nielsen
Kansas City Wizards, #1
Overall Grade: C-





Summary Statement
Nielsen was involved very little in this match (9-10 times) which was dominated on the field by Kansas City. The goal in the 12th minute was deflected off a KC defender. The goal in the 34th minute was primarily due to a poorly played ball by a KC defender.

Nielsen in no way should be faulted for the loss against a struggling DC squad who had yet to win a game in 2010. Although fault can't be placed on Nielsen, there were some flags raised regarding his performance.

The most notable area of improvement for Jimmy Nielsen surrounds his footwork. On both goals it is very clear that Nielsen is not properly setting his feet to prepare for the shot. It's such a small detail, but when your feet are still moving, you're body is still moving, which gives you a fraction less time to react to a shot.

There is also an opportunity for improvement regarding Nielsen's speed and quickness. His feet looked very heavy and he was not moving with the bounce a professional goalkeeper should have (imagine a boxer in the ring) on game day. This may be an injury issue, or an issue with fitness. It wasn't clear during the broadcast if an injury was present. At 32, there is still time to work hard in training and place a focus on maximizing speed and agility.

The most positive aspect of the match for Nielsen was how he played in breakaway/1-on-1 situations. He successfully turned away chances from D.C. on two occasions.


Strengths
Breakaways/1-on-1. Confidence. Angle play.

Weaknesses
Footwork. Speed. Reaction time. Understanding how to deal with weaknesses.

Complete Scorecard:

Technical Abilities: C
  • Hands: Not enough information. Only caught the ball one time on a bouncing through ball.
  • Body Position: Body position is proper. The major issue for Jimmy right now is speed.
  • Diving: The diving form is proper. The speed of his dives are an area of concern.
  • Angles: Did not see anything to indicate great or poor angle play. However, with his lack of speed he may need to adjust his angles to make up for this deficiency.
  • Footwork: Footwork needs to be addressed. In this particular match, Nielsen's footwork was exposed on both goals. Although the goals were not completely due to bad footwork, the technique limited the GK's ability to make the dramatic save. Nielsen needs to set his feet in a ready position a fraction of a second sooner than he was in this match. When the ball is leaving the foot of the shooter, Nielsen's feet are still moving. If you're feet are still moving, you're body is still moving... giving you less of an opportunity to make a proper play on a shot.
  • Diverting: Not enough information.
  • Foot Skills: Collected the ball well using feet/body. Clearances on back passes were shaky.
  • Breakaways/1-on-1: Presented with a 2 on 1 breakaway situation in the 41st minute. Did well to stay on feet, didn't commit too early, and made his best save of the night.


Physical Attributes: D
  • Balance: No grade.
  • Speed: An area of concern. Was clearly beaten (hit post) on a long range set piece that should not have been an issue. One of the announcers mentioned the possibility of an injury… this was not confirmed.
  • Reaction: Reaction time can be tied to other characteristics. I this case, speed and footwork are limiting Nielsen's reaction time.
  • Size: Tall, but not aphysically imposing.
  • Strength: Could benefit from some strength and agility training.


Aerial Intelligence: NO GRADE
  • Preparation: Not enough information. No grade given for category.
  • Decision Making: Not enouth information.
  • Communication: Not enough information.
  • Timing: In the 34th min, a bouncing ball was played into the area from the other GK. Nielsen's technique on this ball was below average. The timing of the jump was off and the ball was not collected at it's peak. Although this was not a very dangerous situation, it could be a symptom of an aerial issue.


Distribution: C
  • Punting/Drop Kicks: Not enough information in my notes.
  • Goal Kicks: Not enough information in my notes.
  • Throwing: Not enough information to grade.
  • Bowling: Not enough information.
  • From Feet: Clearances on back passes were shaky. Other simple balls played well.
  • Decision Making: No poor distribution decisions.


Psychological: B
  • Confidence: Carries himself in a confident manner. Does not appear to be easily rattled.
  • Leadership: Appears to have respect of team. They respond well to his direction.
  • Mental Toughness: Not tested very much in this match. No grade.
  • Courage: Not enough information.
  • Attitude: Positive attitude. No obvious issues here.


Tactical: C
  • Knowledge: Part of goalkeeping is understanding your own strengths, weaknesses, and limitations… and doing what is necessary to shield yourself from having your weaknesses exposed. One way this can be done is with organizing the other resources on the field (teammates) to help in certain situations. The other is individually making decisions to hide your weakness (ex. cheating your angles more to make of for your size or quickness). As Nielsen continues to get older (he's 32 now), he will need to become more reliant on knowledge of the game rather than on an athletic skill set to maximize his longevity in the professional ranks.
  • Decision Making: This grade is primarily based on one play in the 76th minute. DC is set up for a very long free kick from 35+ yards out and Nielsen does not want a wall. A decent shot is struck, bounces, beats Nielsen, and hits the post. With one of his weaknesses on the night being speed/reaction, he should have had a 1-man wall set on the near post to assist with the weakness. This should have not been a dangerous situation for KC and could have been easily avoided with better decision making.
  • Organization/Communication: Communicates with his squad and organizes well. At least one of the tactical decisions was questionable (see above).


Final Result: D
  • Victory/Draw/Loss: Loss by 1. Late goal by Keimara from KC.
  • Shutout: 2 goals.
  • Significance in Result (+/-): One more save could have secured a draw for KC, but Nielsen was not the reason his squad lost this game. Poor balls played out of the back by DC defenders led to the loss.


Uniform Kit: Minus (-)
  • Style: Simple style. Acceptable.
  • Coordination: The jersey and socks are two different, unacceptable shades of yellow. The same kit Dario Sala wore in a previous grade.
  • Color: Neon yellow, mustard yellow, and white.


Key Moments

12 min.
GOAL. Shot from about 16 yards deflects off defender for a goal. Unfortunate for Nielsen and DC. Nielsen could have set his feet a half second sooner, this may have given him a better opportunity to respond to the deflection. It's tough to react to an altered shot when your body is still moving the set for the shot.

22 min.
FOOT SKILL. Shaky foot skill on the handling of a back pass.

34 min.
OFF OF LINE. Poor technique on a ball played from other goal box. Collect the ball above your head at its peak.

34 min.
GOAL. Goal off of intercepted pass. Nielsen played his angle well, but his footwok was once again poor. He was still moving his feet when he should have been set for the shot. If you are still moving, you lose that fraction of a second of reaction time that could mean a save rather than a goal. With that said, this goal was not Neilsen's fault.

41 min.
SAVE. Foot save on a one-on-one. Good save and good work to quickly get back to feet and safely secure the ball.

60 min.
FOOT SKILL. Example of Nielsen speed ball at feet.

61 min.
FOOT SKILL. Example of Nielsen speed ball at feet.

65 min.
SAVE. Good work to stay on his feet and follow the 2-on-1 passing. Clutch save from Nielsen.

76 min.
SHOT OFF POST. Communicated that he did not require a wall. Shot pinged to near side beat Nielsen who is only saved by the post. Slower to get to his right that what I would like to see. Questionable decision on the wall. A one man wall would have been sufficient.


Other Match Notes:
First win of the season for D.C. United.

Friday, May 14, 2010

Bill Hamid - D.C. United - MLS - 05.05.2010

Final: DC United 2, Kansas City Wizards 1
RFK Stadium, Washington D.C.
MLS - Major League Soccer
05/05/2010

Bill Hamid
D.C. United, #28
Overall Grade: B





Summary Statement
Hamid started out the match very shaky, which is understandable considering this was his professional debut. As the macth went on, you could see Hamid becoming more comfortable on the field and communicating with his defenders.

There is an obvious gap in ability on different types of crosses. Hamid does exceptionally well covering corner kicks and crosses from a narrow position. With crosses from a wider angle position (12 yards and out), Hamid struggles with these types of balls. There is some clear indecision and uncertainty on how to properly play these balls.

Overall, I was impressed with the level of play for a 19 year old making his professional debut. His size and stature are impressive. Speed off the line may be an area of improvement.

He has very good hands for a big man. As mentioned, he was shaky in the beginning of the match, and that was clearly displayed in at least one ball being mishandled. Later in the game, his catching technique was superb. Very secure, catching with soft fingertips and the staple 'W' hand formation..

I will be interested in following the progress of this young man as he continues to mature as a player in the MLS. Hamid may also be worth a look by the Men's National Team at the U-20 and U-23 levels.

Strengths
Size. Communication. Crosses from narrow/short angles.

Weaknesses
Crosses from high and wide. Indecision coming off his line. Distracted by potential contact.

Complete Scorecard:

Technical Abilities: B
  • Hands: Early in the game the hand technique was erratic (fumbled the ball coming out for a challenge and akwardly parried a long shot). As Hamid got further into the game, his technique and stability improved.
  • Body Position: Great at times (60th min.). Other times very poor (26th min.).
  • Diving: Strong when covering narrow near post shots.
  • Angles: Fantastic save made in 1st half made purely because of his angle to the shooter. Did very well overall to maximize his angles.
  • Footwork: Average.
  • Diverting: One instance of parrying the ball away on a cross. Diverted into a safe location.
  • Foot Skills: Played the ball well using body and feet.
  • Decision Making: There were multiple instances of indecision on whether to come off his line or not. With that said, no damage.

Physical Attributes: B
  • Balance: Stayed in control of his body well. Kept concious of his location relative to the goal line on a cross in the 60th min. Momentem was pushing him into the box and he did very well to not panic, keep the ball out of the goal, and not give up posession.
  • Speed: Average speed coming off the line.
  • Reaction: Did well on quick shots, especially the save in the 45th minute.
  • Size: 6'3", 225 lbs
  • Strength: Appears physically strong. Handled aerial contact well.

Aerial Intelligence: C
  • Preparation: Good positioning and prep-footwork for crossing situations.
  • Decision Making: Definite area of improvement. Indecision can lead to goals.
  • Communication: Clear, simple, loud communication to other squad members.
  • Timing: When Hamid commits, he does well. When there is indecision, timing is off.

Distribution: B
  • Punting/Drop Kicks: Decent distance, accuracy, and weight.
  • Goal Kicks: Decent distance and weight. Not great, not bad.
  • Throwing: Not enough information.
  • Bowling: Not enough information.
  • From Feet: long & well played into opponents end of the field.
  • Decision Making: No mistakes or poor distribution decisions.

Psychological: C
  • Confidence: This is Bill's first professional game. With time and success, this will naturally improve.
  • Leadership: In the first match for the 19 year old, there is no expectation for this category.
  • Mental Toughness: Did very well to maintain composure in first professional match
  • Courage: Hesitated and took eyes off the ball when presented with potential contact. With his stature, he should be less fearful than those entering his goal area.
  • Attitude: Positive.

Tactical: B
  • Knowledge: No grade.
  • Decision Making: Tactically, no major mistakes.
  • Organization/Communication: For a 19 year old rookie playing his first game, I was really impressed with how vocal Hamid was in the match. He was providing loud, clear, and simple communication. He appeared lost on a couple occassions where he may have been uncomfortable or unsure on set piece set-up.
Match Result: B
  • Victory/Draw/Loss: Win. First win of the season for D.C.
  • Shutout (1) or (0): Unfortunate goal allowed in extra time.
  • Significance in Result (+/-): First game as a professional is a win. First win of the season for D.C.

Uniform Kit:
Fun category that can apply a plus or minus to grade.
  • Style: Simple style. Acceptable.
  • Coordination: Coordinates entire ensamble well. Matches DC United color schem
  • Color: All red. Works well.

Key Moments

3 min.
CROSS. Shaky coming off the line for the first challenge of the match. Took eyes off the ball which led to the fumble.

17 min.
SAVE. Good save on point blank shot. A touch of hesitation by Hamid almost created a big problem. Well done to recover from misdecision.

20 min.
CROSS. Nice work to snag a narrow cross at near post while at it's peak.

26 min.
SAVE. Hard shot from 30 yards out punched away. Body position was erractic. His nerves appear to be elevated (understandable) but he needs to do better to control his body and the direction of his diversion (or catch the ball).

29 min.
CROSS. Came off the line a secuely captured the ball. Good communication and subsequent quick outlet throw.

33 min.
DISTRIBUTION. Goal kick.

39 min.
CORNER KICK. Parryed a corner kick out of danger

42 min.
CROSS. Amid hesitates again coming off his line and is distracted by potential contact on a cross. Lucky that the
attacker misplayed the ball as well.

45 min.
DISTRIBUTION. Ball played deep into other area from ground.

45+1 min.
SAVE. Great reaction save made possible by perfect positioning in front of goal and with his angles.

45+2 min.
COMMUNICATION. Loud, simple, clear, direction to teammates. "Keeper", "Away", Step Up". When I can hear you from the stands, you are communicating properly. However, he still appears out of his element when applying the proper team tactic to his defense… this will come with more playing time.

46 min.
SAVE. Shot from wout wide was saved at the near post. Rebound given up for subsequest corner kick.

46 min.
CORNER KICK. Good work to get to corner kick and punch away from danger. Took some contact.

48 min.
DISTRIBUTION. Punt. Great distance and weight on punt from top of own box to tope of other box.

57 min.
SAVE. Safely covered a narrow angle shot to the near post.

60 min.
CROSS. Kept concious of his location relative to the goal line on a cross. Momentem was pushing him into the box
and he did very well to not panic, keep the ball out of the goal, and not give up posession.

63 min.
COMMUNICATION. Example of communication.

73 min.
CROSS. Nicely secured ball on a low dangerous cross. Soft hands, good technique on dificult ball at chest level.

80 min.
FOOT SKILL. Good one time clearance to half field from back-pass.

85 min.
CROSS. Long cross into box. Bill comes off his line but does not challenge for ball. If the attacker got to the ball with his head, Bill was in a very vulnerable postion.

92 min.
GOAL. Unfortunate injury time goal to spoil the shutout. Very well placed by KC's Keimara. DC defense caught sleeping with 2 men open on the back post. A potential opportunity of improvement for Hamid is to stay in the game until the end and keep his defence focus and organized.

FINAL

Other Match Notes:
Youngest goalkeeper in MLS to win a game. 4 days younger than Tim Howard.
First win of the season for D.C. United.

Sunday, May 2, 2010

Donovan Ricketts - L.A. Galaxy - MLS - 04.24.2010

Final: L.A. Galaxy 0, Kansas City Wizards 0
Community America Ballpark, Kansas City, KS
MLS - Major League Soccer
04/24/210

Donovan Ricketts
L.A. Galaxy, #1
Overall Grade: B+

Summary Statement
Ricketts is a physically large and powerful man with insane athletic ability. There is a huge opportunity for improvement with the technical and aerial aspects of his game. With an intense and consistent trianing focus on cleaning up technique and improving some of the distribution decision making, Ricketts coule prove to be a dominant goalkeeper in the MLS and possibly position himself for promotion to a more prominent league.

Strengths
Innate shot stopping ability. Distribution distance.

Weaknesses
Giving up rebounds. Aerial decision making. Distribution accuracy.



Complete Scorecard:

Technical Abilities: C
Catching technique is okay, borderline sloppy/lazy at times. Was caught on multiple occassions with body not square to field and ball falling behind him. Did very well to get to shots from side-to-side. Does not appear confident with the ball at his feet. With that said, no mistakes made.

Physical Attributes: A
Physically very large man. Very quick with good balance and exceptional strength.

Aerial Intelligence: C
Primarily sits in the goal mouth on crosses. Given Donovan's size, I'd like to see him take more command of his box.

Distribution: B
Low driving punts on a short field are causing problems for opponent. Ball delivered occasionally into other box from feet (short field). Nearly every ball was played long in this match. This could be tactical of the short field (played in a minor league baseball stadium). LA was never given the opportunity to build the ball out of the back because of these choices.

Psychological: B

Tactical: C

Match Result: B

Uniform Kit: Plus (+)
Fun category that can apply a plus or minus to grade. Nice and simple, gets the plus! I'd be more of a fan if the shirt was tucked, though. Red and black shoes are questionable. Plain all-black adidas kit.

Key Moments

16th min.
A goal was nullified in the 16th min. after a beautiful through-ball was played. Ricketts came out quickly but the ball got past him. Not much he could do. Goal was nullified when player slipped and fell on the ball with his arm while the ball was on the goal line. Galaxy are very fortunate not to be a goal down.

31st min.
Came far off his line to punch a ball in the 31st min. Probably could have simply caught the ball rather than leaving himself vulnerable to a quick chip.

39th min.
Turn around shot in 39th min from about 21-22 yards. Shot was right at keeper which was batted down under control, keeping the ball directly in-front of his body. Positioning was only 2 yards off the goal line and down on a knee. Don't drop to your knee, stay on your feet. Ricketts also needs to be out around the 6 yard line to take better advantage of his angles.

51st min.
Decent positioning on a dangerous ball driven low to the back post. Attacker could not get a clean hit on the ball.

53rd min.
Poorly played a simple cross into the box. Looked like the cross caught him off guard. His jump was poorly timed and the ball rolled off the fingertips into a potentially dangerous spot.

55th min.
Did well to get in front of a hard shot from the top of the box. Rebound left in dangerous spot.

57th min.
Good save on shot. Rebound given up again and cleared by LA defender.

58th min.
Cross sent in and could have done better to gather ball at his highest point. He waited for ball to come into his chest.

67th min.
Great point blank save made purely because of good positioning.

81st min.
Hard shot from top of box. Well handled but he fell to knees again. Body was not square to the field. Poor quick outlet throw to Klein.


Other Match Notes:
Very soggy and slippery pitch.
Super narrow field and short field (70 yds. wide x 100 yds. long).
Played inside a minor league baseball park while KC's new stadium is being built.
Ricketts named the "Man of the Match".

Popular Posts